© 2025 Evan D. Garner
Audio of this sermon can be heard here. Video can be seen here.
Once upon a time, a group of clergy went on an ecumenical pilgrimage to the Holy Land. They represented a dozen denominations from their small, southern town, and, even though their churches rarely worked together, the clergy were interested in building meaningful relationships across sectarian boundaries.
To the great frustration of the Episcopal priest on the trip, he was assigned as his roommate the pastor of the large non-denominational church in town. As far as that priest was concerned, the trip and everything it represented would be better if that pastor had stayed at home. His sermons about women and marriage and immigrants and the need for faithful Christians to resist the cultural slide into apostasy that had infected American culture were pretty much everything that Episcopal priest thought was wrong with contemporary Christianity. And now they were roommates.
All throughout the trip, the pastor took pictures with his phone, effortlessly crafting compelling social media posts about how he felt the Lord’s presence when he stood in those sacred places where Jesus had been. And, every time, the Episcopal priest did whatever he could to stay out of those pictures. “I don’t want any part of his manipulation of this pilgrimage to serve his ungodly purposes,” the priest whispered to a sympathetic colleague.
When they came to the Jordan River and the place where John the Baptist had baptized Jesus, the tour guide invited the participants to come down into the river and reclaim their baptismal identity and seek the renewal of the Holy Spirit as they splashed themselves with the sacred water. The priest seized the opportunity, thinking to himself that if there was any hope for the renewal of Christianity it was here, in the place where John had helped God’s people prepare their hearts and minds to receive the Messiah by repenting of their sinful ways.
The priest practically ran down the bank, strode confidently into the water, immersed himself beneath its surface, and stood up with outstretched arms, praying, “I thank you God that I am an Episcopalian and that I am not like other Christians who think that your word should be a weapon to serve their agenda. I show up at protests and rallies and march in the Pride parade every year. I drive an electric vehicle and eat vegetarian meals three times a week to combat climate change. I give ten percent of my income to the church in support of its work of sharing your love with all people.”
When he was finished praying, the priest looked all around for his roommate who, to his surprise, had disappeared from view. Walking back to the bus, he encountered the pastor, who was coming up from a part of the river that was out of sight of the other clergy. “What were you doing down there,” the priest asked scornfully, “filming another TikTok video for your flock?”
“No,” the pastor replied gently. “This was the place where God’s people came out to heed the prophet’s call of repentance. Baptism is something that all Christians share. These waters proclaim a hope in God’s love and mercy that are far bigger than me or my ministry. I didn’t feel worthy enough to try to capture that in a social media post, so I walked down there, where no one could see me, and said my prayers quietly.”
The tour guide who overheard the exchange leaned over to the bus driver and said, “I tell you, this man is going home justified rather than the other; for all who exalt themselves will be humbled, and all who humble themselves will be exalted.”
I love the parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector. I think we all do. But it’s easier to love it when we can see ourselves in the humility of the penitent sinner and hold the arrogance of the self-righteous narcissist at arm’s length. But, if we’re honest, is there anyone more likely to trust in their own righteousness and regard others with contempt than Episcopalians?
Deep down, though, I think there’s a little bit of both in all of us. All of us are a mixture of self-confidence and self-doubt—of religious pride and religious fear. Some of us tend more toward one side than the other, but all of us need the same grace. And, in this parable, Jesus teaches us that true faithfulness is complete and utter dependence upon that grace no matter who you are.
Two thousand years later, we are so familiar with the stereotypes of Pharisees and tax collectors that we need some help reimagining this parable or else we’ll be guilty of assuming that Jesus’ words are intended for someone else and have nothing to teach us. We forget just how religious and faithful and holy the Pharisees really were. We imagine that all of them were hypocrites because that’s the way they are usually portrayed in the gospel, but the faithfulness of the Pharisees was generally above reproach. They were the kinds of generous, prayerful people whom any rabbi would love to have serve on the synagogue’s vestry. But, when good and faithful people forget that their acts of faithfulness do not make them better than anyone else, their religion quickly becomes an exercise in self-righteous condemnation.
Tax collectors, on the other hand, were paragons of faithlessness. They made their living doing the very worst thing imaginable: extorting money from their neighbors in order to support the oppressive empire and line their own pockets with the proceeds. They were partners in crime with the enemies of God and God’s people, and it was safe to assume that they had long ago given up on any hope of redemption. But even the very worst sinner imaginable—even the one whose entire life seems devoted to everything God stands against—is loved by God and redeemed by grace.
Where on that spectrum of Pharisee and tax collector do you fall today? Are you like the Pharisee, who finds it hard to believe that God’s grace and mercy are just as much a part of the lives of your enemies as your own? Or are you like the tax collector, who has a hard time believing that God’s grace and mercy are meant for you as well? All of us need God’s grace, and all of us are called to recognize that God’s grace belongs to all people.
This church and its people do amazing things. We believe that our doors should be open to everyone. We believe that anyone who feels drawn to this table is welcomed here, not only by Jesus but by all of us. We believe that sharing God’s love with the world means more than preaching sermons and teaching Bible studies. We think loving others in Jesus’ name means feeding hungry people and helping those who are unhoused find a secure place to call home. And we do all of those good and godly things not because we are better than anyone else or because we think that God will love us more if we do them. We do those things because we know that God has loved us and forgiven us and redeemed us in Jesus Christ and because people who know the power of that love cannot keep it to themselves.
Today is Celebration Sunday, when we invite every household in the church to make a financial commitment to God’s work in the world for the coming year. Today, we invite you to do what that Pharisee did—to give ten percent of your income back to God. But, if you’re planning to fill out your estimate of giving card because you think that makes you better than other people or because your generosity puts you first in line to receive God’s blessings, don’t do it. You’d be better off putting that card in your pocket and taking it home and asking God to help you remember that God’s love belongs equally to everyone before giving one penny to the church.
Everything we do as an expression of our relationship with God must be a response to God’s love, not a prerequisite for it. Saying our prayers, reading the Bible, going to church, loving our neighbor, serving the poor, and giving money back to God—all of that is done in gratitude for God’s grace, not in search of God’s mercy. When thankfulness is the root motivation for our spiritual practices, including stewardship, those practices deepen our relationship with God. When we’re trying to earn God’s favor through them, they undermine that relationship instead.
As soon as we allow ourselves to believe that God loves some people more than others, we will find a way to convince ourselves either that we’re the ones whom God loves best or we’re the ones whom God will never love. And neither of those is right. God loves you. In Jesus, God has made you worthy. Through Christ, God has invited you to sit down at God’s banquet table where you belong alongside everyone else. Let your generosity reinforce that belief by making it a way for you to proclaim the greatness of the Lord. Let your stewardship be a way of rejoicing in God’s salvation for you and all people.